If what Edna Chun says is true, that she was pressured into
revealing names that should have been kept confidential and that she was
working in a hostile work environment, doesn’t that demonstrate that A. there
are significant problems in HR with confidentiality and B. She doesn’t know how
to address the very situations for which she was hired? So, she has admitted failure
(revealing names) and incompetence (inability to address a hostile work
environment). I wouldn’t think she’d need a lot more than that to explain why
she was fired.
And what about Benita Peace in all of this? It would seem to
me that since Chun has been sent packing, Peace should be pushing things into a
suitcase too. If Chun has been fired for the reasons that the university would
like to provide as legal reasons for non-renewal (as opposed to because she was
Asian and 68). After all, the main difference between Chun and Peace then seems
to be age (Peace is 59, Chun 68) and race (Peace is African-American, Chun is
Asian-American).
In which case, Chun is correct, she was treated differently
and is being dismissed as a result of race and age.
I’m sorry, I think I just opened up a wormhole in the
universe.
Let me see if this still makes sense:
Either, Chun was fired because of failure and incompetence
which means that Peace should be fired too.
Or, she was fired because of her race and age, which would
be demonstrated by Peace having not been fired.
So…UNCG should either fire Peace or admit to racism and
ageism…which sounds like a HR problem…and should definitely lead to some lost
jobs for their supervisors as the very things for which they were ostensibly
fired (failure and incompetence.) Which might mean that Charlie Maimone should
be fired (and he’s white, so that would truly demonstrate that the firings
weren’t about race…I haven’t the foggiest idea how old he is). If he isn’t
fired, it must be because Chun is lying…a perfectly good reason to fire her.
Ouch, my head hurts.
Add to that, though, the fact that when Chun was fired from
her position in HR at Broward, she filed a grievance claiming discrimination
AND she was fired because of claims of discrimination.
This is a twisted mess.
I wouldn’t be surprised if even Stephen Hawking wouldn’t be
able to explain UNCG’s Big Bang.
A bunch of people are going to be looking to spin plausible deniability.
ReplyDelete